Category Archives: Articles

Should Actuaries be NICE?

The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) is the independent organisation responsible for providing national guidance on the promotion of good health and the prevention and treatment of ill health. Their guidance is supposed to take into account both clinical and cost effectiveness but many of their decisions can appear arbitrary.

For example, NICE have restricted the use of donepezil (Aricept), galantamine (Reminyl), and rivastigmine (Exelon) for patients in the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease, forcing patients to wait for their condition to deteriorate and worsen before these drugs can be proscribed. Lucentis, a drug designed to save eyesight is likewise restricted for many relevant conditions.

Although there are savings to be made on the cost of the drugs themselves (if not prescribed) in conditions such as those above, even in purely economic terms these are surely outweighed by the resulting long-term care that will be needed in cases of Alzheimer’s and blindness (the Alzheimer’s drugs in question cost just £2.50/day). This is an area where the involvement of actuaries in the decision making process could be greatly beneficial as actuaries have applied common-sense and a tool-box of transferable skills.

An ageing demographic, increased longevity and the spiralling cost of long-term care need to be addressed by a review of pensions provision and where decisions concerning medical treatment are likely to affect the long term care needs of the patient, it is of direct interest to actuaries. The actuarial profession should lead the way and should be actively involved in this crucial decision making process.

Innovative Distribution Channels

Which innovations will impact the financial industry and the banking and insurance sectors in 2009? How do the innovative capabilities of the UK compare to the rest of the world and how effective are the latest IT solutions across the financial sector?

Three major figures in the financial industry – Dr Geraldine Kaye, Jacques Kemp and Husamettin Dogramaci answer these questions and reveal the secrets to using the internet to increase revenues and develop closer relationships with clients.

Innovative Distribution Channels

Register for actuarial jobs at www.GAAPS.com

Statistical Analysis of Vacancies on The Actuary Jobs

The Actuary Magazine has an online job search facility The Actuary Jobs. As vacancies are uploaded by both employers and a selection of recruiters, we decided to assume that is representative of the range of actuarial opportunities currently available. The initial aim was to produce a statistical analysis of the vacancies available on The Actuary Jobs in order to create a picture of the current actuarial job market.

Which sectors have the most vacancies? And at which levels of experience? Are there significant differences in salary across sectors? How great are the increases in salary between different career stages – from recent graduates to experienced actuaries?

First I entered the data for the number of vacancies by sector. As shown in Graph 1, there are significantly more vacancies advertised for General and Life positions than for any other sector.

Vacancies by Sector

Vacancies by Sector


Graph 1

The next stage was to investigate how these vacancies subdivided by career stage. (Graph 2) The job search facility recognises 8 distinct career stages from undergraduate through to experienced.

Actuarial vacancies subdivided by sector and career stage

Actuarial vacancies subdivided by sector and career stage


Graph 2

At first glance it appears that once a candidate has commenced their actuarial studies there does not seem to be a significant difference in the number of vacancies available at the various career stages within a sector.

Actuarial Vacancies by Salary Range

Actuarial Vacancies by Salary Range


Graph 3

The situation appears even stranger when looking at the salaries available at each career stage (Graph 3). There are vacancies available for experienced actuaries within the lowest pay-band of £20,000 – £29,000 and it would seem that there are positions available where actuarial students, at the beginning of their career, will be able to command a salary in excess of £120,000!

The solution lies in the way that vacancies have been uploaded to the jobsearch facility. Once vacancy for a head of pricing, responsible for dealing with senior management lists the experience required as “Actuarial Student, Ex-student, Part Qualified, Nearly / Newly Qualified, Qualified, Experienced”. Therefore, this position is included as a vacancy at every career stage, rendering statistical analysis of the data impossible. More importantly is the effect that this will have on candidates using this facility to search for a job.

Visitors to The Actuary Jobs are invited to choose from a selection of criteria (sector, level, salary) in order to create a short list of appropriate vacancies. Understandably there may be some overlap between career stages, a vacancy may be suitable either for someone who is Nearly / Newly Qualified or for someone Qualified, but to list every career stage for one vacancy, as in the example above, renders the search facility useless. Candidates using The Actuary Jobs search facility will not be able to obtain a short list that is any more meaningful that the full list of vacancies.

It is imperative for employers and recruiters to carefully consider their choice of keywords when uploading a vacancy. At present, this does not appear to be the case.

Pick up a copy of…

This month’s Recruiter magazine features as article by GAAPS’s own Head of Research, Sima Varsani. Sima writes about the things many candidates will face when relocating abroad. Having learned the trials and tribulations of the big move down under whilst undergoing her secondment for GAAPS in our Brisbane office, Sima has summarised many of the main issues that should not be overlooked when relocating: visas, budgets, taxes and may other things you’ve probably never thought about.

“Ultimately, relocation is a personal decision. We advise our candidates to take a holiday in the country they are considering, preferably combined with face-to-face interviews,” writes Sima.

Don’t be afraid to give us a call and ask us about our many opportunities abroad; Sima and the entire gang at GAAPS are here to help make it happen!

Go here to read the online version of Sima’s article.

A Fresh Approach to Human Researching

by Chaim Coutts

from the UK Trade and Investment (British Embassy, Tel Aviv) newsletter:

Last year, Liverpool FC offered a large contract to Israeli football star Yossi Benayoun. This was all made possible by a football agent who had negotiated this contract for Yossi…

The use of agents is not restricted to the sports industry. There are industry-specific agents searching and selecting qualified candidates for the financial services sector worldwide.

My name is Chaim Coutts, and I have worked in the Executive Search/Recruitment industry for the last four and a half years; I am an affiliate of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries in the UK. Although I am based in London, my experience extends across Europe, North America and the Middle East.

So what would you say if you were to see this kind of unique search and selection service within the financial services sector in Israel in the very near future?

In general, there are three ways of sourcing the best candidate for a specific job:

1.) from your own, existing contacts

2.) from your own company supply database of candidates, or

3.) from a more active approach, which would entail a search mission, or what is more colloquially known as ‘headhunting’.

In both of these latter cases, a meeting is needed with the specific client to know exactly what the company requires with regards to the candidates’ skills, experience and personality.

You may ask why companies need this consultancy service, because, in theory, one would imagine that it is part of the Human Resources role to find the right candidate.

A majority of the companies are not always fully aware of the high-quality candidates available in the market, or of their attractive skills. This is especially true for overseas companies. The idea of international job changes and movement across the globe has gradually become more and more popular over the last decade. This trend is likely to continue. The task of knowing and learning about the good quality candidates in the market is clearly a separate profession, complementing HR and easing the load on them.

One of the main services that I can offer to Israeli companies is for my team and I to use our knowledge of the financial sector, ranging from banks to insurance companies, wealth management houses, fund management, hedge funds and investment banks and provide the right candidates for your business to grow.

Information Underload

The following letter was printed in the August 2008 edition of The Actuary.

Your July 2008 edition referred to the revised situation regarding work permits, making entry to the UK more difficult. It appears that, as an industry, we may soon find ourselves with a skills shortage due to inaction. If we want to avoid a serious personnel deficit over the next few years, we need to start taking note of where these staff shortages occur.

I wish to give actuaries, and the Profession in general, a more detailed update of what has been happening ‘behind the scenes’, having worked actively on this matter since the end of 2006, when the classification of the industry was officially altered.

After raising queries and complaints about this alteration, I was invited to the Home Office. Accompanied by the chief executive of the Institute of Actuaries, I met with two members of the Home Office’s Operational Policy team to discuss the situation in May 2007.

We discovered that, in order to get actuaries back on the shortage list, it would be necessary for the Financial Services Skills Council to collect robust data substantiating a shortage. It was decided that the Institute would investigate further. The chief executive of the Institute requested authority from various committees to research and collect such data, but to date there has been no significant progress.

I was contacted in June to say that a new shortage list was being compiled — again, without the inclusion of actuaries, unless they received immediate information confirming a shortage.

It is too late to change the situation this time around but in order to make a difference for the next renewal, robust data must be collated. Without evidence, the limitations will continue and so will the staff shortages.

If you are an employer experiencing a shortage – whether it be at graduate, part qualified or qualified level, please e-mail me at gkaye@gaaps.com and I will organise a meeting of relevant parties.

Dr Geraldine Kaye
3 July 2008

Pay for the Piper

By Dr. Geraldine Kaye

When looking at the remuneration package that comes with an executive directorship or any other position high up the corporate pecking order, one’s eyes naturally go to the headline salary quoted in the newspaper, by the head hunter or wherever.  But this is only one component – admittedly it is usually the biggest  – of the total on offer.  Often the monetary value of additional fringe benefits can add up to well over 50% of basic salary.

One of the most expensive ‘extras’ is membership of an occupational pension scheme.  If this is of the ‘final salary’ type (where benefits are expressed as a percentage of earnings at retirement), the cost to the employer will increase dramatically with the employee’s age.  There is currently a marked trend towards retiring earlier and earlier. Where executive directors and other senior employees are concerned, many employers offer more generous early retirement benefits than those set out in the pension scheme rules.  Much will depend on the financial state of the company pension fund – is it in healthy surplus or does it need topping up by the employer?

Pensions come with important fiscal incentives, for both employee and employer.  This is why the Government has almost a paranoia about the potential for tax planning manipulation, especially where high earning employees are concerned.  The earnings that can be taken into account in calculating maximum benefits and tax relievable contributions are now ‘capped’ at a maximum limit, which is set at £84,000 for the current 1997/98 tax year.  For earnings above the ‘cap’, an employer may offer membership of an ‘unapproved pension scheme’.  Although this type of arrangement does not have the usual tax advantages, there are still fiscal benefits to be had from it.

There are, of course, a whole range of other perks that can come with basic salary.  Company cars may be taxed more severely than in the past, but, even after allowing for the Inland Revenue’s take, the net benefit of a car is usually worth more than its salary equivalent.  The tax the employees pay will depend on the mileage clocked up on company business.  They should always try to ensure that they qualify for the highest mileage/lowest tax band that they can achieve in their particular role within the business.

Tax-free profit related pay is being phased out, but it will still be available until the end of 1999.  There are also share option schemes.  The value of such a facility will depend very largely on the success or otherwise of the business and its impact on the share price.  In their capacity within the company, that will largely be up to the executive directors and other senior staff who participate in the arrangement!

Most company pension schemes come with added life assurance cover.  The employer pays the premiums, which are tax relievable as an allowable business expense.  If the worst should happen and an employee should die before retirement, the lump sum benefit will normally be payable to people nominated by that individual and there should be no inheritance tax to pay.

A number of companies offer disability income replacement insurance for their employees.  Sometimes this is available to the whole work force and sometimes to only the upper echelons of executive staff.  The insurance company takes over responsibility for salary payments after a waiting, or ‘deferred’, period of usually between one month and two years.  The benefits continue until the individual is fit enough to return to work, leaves the company, dies or reaches retirement age – whichever should happen first.  The cost to the employer is normally a very small percentage of the employee’s basic salary.

Private medical insurance is an important benefit for the employing company as well as its executive staff.  Lengthy NHS hospital waiting lists are avoided, admission is at a time chosen by the patient (and employer) rather than the healthcare provider, and, with table, laptop computer and telephone, the individual is often able to carry on working in the private room provided.

Soaring headline rates of pay for executive directors of plcs has been attracting the attention of the media for all the wrong reasons.  The storm started with the packages awarded to people running recently privatised utilities, often in virtual monopoly situations.  But it has now spread to other parts of the public company spectrum.  One major difficulty is that these individuals may, with their gifts for organisation and generating profits for the business that employs them, actually earn their inflated salaries, but that message is not being communicated effectively to the outside world.

In the life assurance company sector, we have noticed that the key duties of  ‘appointed actuary’ are increasingly being carried out, not by executive directors but by outside consultants.  Could we see this tendency extend to other roles and other types of business?  It could be a way of circumnavigating the open disclosure of executive directors’ remuneration issue!

Future for Actuarial Profession is Safe

Fears that the actuarial profession will suffer as a result of the decline of defined benefits are laid to rest.  According to this article in the recent online addition of Global Pensions, actuaries are keen, diverse, able to leap tall buildings (in our humble opinion), and will continue to be in demand.

Possibly one of the largest – and most contentious – growth areas for the actuarial profession is the rise of the ‘implemented consultant’ or ‘fiduciary manager’. Although the two terms carry slightly different connotations, they share many of the same elements, not least the actuarial involvement in schemes.

Not sure if/how you will fit in?  Top roles for qualified actuaries have become more difficult to find, creating a need for specialised recruitment.  The need for actuaries is so great, according to Dr. Geraldine Kaye, MD at GAAPS Actuarial, that she, as a strong believer in the skills of actuaries, has been working diligently at getting actuaries included in the Highly Skilled Migrant Workers permit programme so that companies with long-standing vacancies can fill those roles.  “With the credit crunch hitting the headlines, GAAPS has never been busier.  The UK actuarial profession does not seem to have been hit in the same way as other areas of financial services in terms of redundancies.”

GAAPS on the Barbie

Our GAAPS girl down under, Sima, has graced the webpages of The Actuary this month.  Sima tells us a little something about her secondment in Brisbane and how to make a smooth move to Oz.

In terms of my first impressions, it’s not like Neighbours! Brisbane strikes me as a bustling, cosmopolitan city. With the Brisbane River winding through, the atmosphere is different – it’s not easy to put my finger on – but it has a pleasant harmony.